Saturday, January 9, 2010

Did El Naschie steal M. Helmy Said's theory?


That is the serious charge being made by an Egyptian scientist, inventor and artist now living in Finland.


Said made the accusation at an Islam Online discusion about El Naschie. (The link goes to an Arabic Web page. We do not supply the Google translation link because Google Translate often, as in this case, does not translate comments.) Here are Said's own words:


النظرية التي كان يتمناها النشائي هي نظريتي عن البعد الخامس في الفيزياء وهي وباعتراف النشائي ثورة في العلم واختلفنا وباعدت بيننا الايام عندما حاول ان ينسبها لنفسه
نظريتي منشوره علي هذا الرابط
http://www.5thdth.net/theory.htm

Theory, which was hoping for El Naschie is my theory on the fifth dimension in physics and are recognized El Naschie revolution in science and disagree, and pushing us the days when he tried to attribute to himself
My theory posted on this link
http://www.5thdth.net/theory.htm


A careful reading of the online manuscript of Said's theory, The Theory of Infinity for the Fifth Dimension of Space-Time, reveals that El Naschie did actually have the opportunity to appropriate Said's ideas; the third reference in the manuscript is to a private communication between the two scientists, which took place as early as November 2005.

Said was educated at Helwan University in Cairo, and worked at the prestigious Vakola Centre of Research. A polymath, Said is internationally known both for his ergonomic and safety-oriented inventions, and for his evocative portraiture.

Mohammad Mustafa, a strong defender of El Naschie and proprietor of the M.S. El Naschie Scientific Homepage, has responded angrily to Said's allegation:


الى الاخ المدعى على الدكتور محمد النشائى
محمد مصطفى - 2009-12-15 18:14 (GMT)
من الواضح انك تعانى من مرض نفسى خطير و انصحك بان تستشير احد دكاترة الامراض النفسية و العصبية . كيف بالله عليك يقوم الدكتور محمد النشائى بسرقة نظريتك التى تتحدث عن البعد الخامس. يا سيدى الفاضل نظرية الدكتور محمد تقوم على اساس اننا نعيش فى لا نهاية من الابعاد و ليست اربعة او خمسة او حتى عشرة . ثانيا انت بنفسك تعترف بعلم الدكتور النشائى عندما وضعته فى مراجعك فكيف يقوم بسرقة نظريتك و نظريتك مرجعها اليه ؟؟؟؟ اتقى الله فيما تقول

أخبر عن إساءة

Brother to the defendant, Dr. Mohamed El Naschie
Mohammad Mustafa - 2009-12-15 18:14 (GMT)
Clearly you are suffering from serious mental illness and I advise you to consult one of the doctors of psychiatric and neurological. How in God, you, Dr. Mohamed El Naschie stealing your theory, which talks about the fifth dimension. Ya Sidi Mohamed Fadil theory based on the basis that we live in is not the end of the dimensional and not four or five or even ten. Second, you recognize yourself with the knowledge of Dr. El Naschie when put him in Mrajek How is stealing your theory and your theory its reference to???? With fears Allaah says

Refer Ill


There is so far no indication that El Naschie's legal firm, Collyer Bristow, intends to take action against M. Helmy Said.
Translate English to Arabic


محمد النشائي El Naschie Watch محمد النشائي El Naschie News محمد النشائي
محمد النشائي All El Naschie All The Time محمد النشائي

StumbleUpon.com

4 comments:

  1. الي الاستاذ محمد مصطفي
    انا لم اقل سوي الحقيقه ان الدكتور النشائي عندما كان منتظر جائزة نوبل في عام 2005 قال في نظريتي كلام عظيم وبعدها اسندار برأيه 180 درجه وانه قال لي بالخرف الواحد بعد ان قال كل شيئ سلبي عنها انه يعمل في هذا الموضوع منذ 10 سنوات , فأذا كنت انت مكاني واجد القول الجيد ووعد بالنشر وعندي خطابات بخط يده علي نقاط التصحيح من اجل النشر في مجلته ان ذتك, وبعدها يتغير القول, الا تقلق ؟ وانا غير محتاج لان اذهب الي دكتور نفسي لاني اعرف قيمة ما اعمل, وانا اعذرك لانك تحب النشائي وهذا شأنك ولا لوم عليك. واسف في التأخير في الرد لانني لم اقرأ تعليقك الا اليوم والسلام

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for commenting, M. Helmy Said.

    Google's translation is bad but here it is:

    To Mr. Mohamed Mostafa
    I did not say but the truth that Dr. Alnchaii when he expected the Nobel Prize in 2005, said in theory a great talk and then Asendar opinion 180 degrees and he told me dementia one after that said everything negative about that works on this subject 10 years ago, If you are a I find my seat and say good and I have promised to publish letters in his handwriting on the points of the patch for publication in his magazine that Ztk, and then changed to say, but worry? I do not need to go to the Dr. myself because I know the value of work, and I love you because you Amak Alnchaiy and that's your business not blame you. He regretted the delay in reply because I did not read your comment today, but peace


    I just realized that Mohamed Mustafa is probably the proprietor of http://mohamed-elnaschie.blogspot.com/. Said is responding to Mustafa's attack on him. Can anyone give a better translation? I think Said's saying he told nothing but the truth, El Naschie reversed himself, and Said would have responded sooner but hadn't read Mustafa's criticism.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The good news that they published my theory about fifth dimension in scientific journal.
    Please if you find this interesting replay me, thank you
    Dear Professor Said
    Your paper is published in the Volume 7, Issues 1 & 2, February & April 2013, Pages 41-46. Content of the issue is available on our webpage:
    http://www.iphsci.com/the_fifth__dimension__equation.pdf
    Attached please find online version of your article. We shall send reprints soon.
    Referee Report of the paper entitled
    The Fifth Dimension Equations by M. Helmy Said
    In this paper, the author has solved the problems of particles in speed under speed of light C and has solved the problems of particles in speed up than speed of light C.
    The study is new and results are significant and are of interest for the readers.
    I recommend its publication in the JPMS.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The good news that they published my theory about fifth dimension in scientific journal.
    Please if you find this interesting replay me, thank you
    Dear Professor Said
    Your paper is published in the Volume 7, Issues 1 & 2, February & April 2013, Pages 41-46. Content of the issue is available on our webpage:
    http://www.iphsci.com/the_fifth__dimension__equation.pdf
    Attached please find online version of your article. We shall send reprints soon.
    Referee Report of the paper entitled
    The Fifth Dimension Equations by M. Helmy Said
    In this paper, the author has solved the problems of particles in speed under speed of light C and has solved the problems of particles in speed up than speed of light C.
    The study is new and results are significant and are of interest for the readers.
    I recommend its publication in the JPMS.

    ReplyDelete