Monday, February 15, 2010

Two men. Only one can be champion

Today's headline match pits elsheshtwi, representing science and rationality, against scorpion300, representing golden mean mysticism. The referee will be Jumaili.


Elsheshtwi is a careful, methodical fighter, well-known for systematically documenting and numbering each assertion. But scorpion300 may have an edge in raw emotion. His famous trademark attack is to accuse opponents of being Said Elnashaie, confusing and disorienting them.

This exchange was unusual in that it contained large amounts of both English and Arabic. I machine translated the Arabic into English, and left what was originally written in English alone.

The presentation here is better, I think, than the original at Arab Physicists Forum. I have deleted duplications of large blocks of text. Many links were screwed up and have been fixed, though several were beyond repair due to 404 errors, missing cookies, and the like. I have added my comments in red, and some additional links to provide clarification.

Gentlemen: There will be no eye gouging, head butting, or punching below the belt. May the best man win.

Diiinnnng!

Old 11-05-2008, 01:14 PM 11-05-2008, 01:14 PM
elsheshtwi


Fact, Dr. Alnchaiy [El Naschie's name in Arabic is translated by Google into Alnchaiy or Alnchaii.]

القول الشافى فى حقيقة النشائى Shafi said, in fact Alnchaiy

أرجو أن يكون هذا التعليق هو نواة نقاش موضوعى يهدف لمعرفة الحقيقة وليس الهدف هو التشهير. I hope that this comment is the nucleus of a substantive debate aims to find out the truth and are not intended for defamation

We are facing a phenomenon which is not

ظاهرة النشائى وظهوره المكثف فى وسائل الأعلام وإعلانه عن إنجازاته الضخمة فى مجال علم الفيزياء التي تفوق إنجازات كل Phenomenon Alnchaiy and intense appearance in the media and its announcement of the huge achievements in the field of physics that surpass the achievements of each
من نيوتن وأينشتاين. Of Newton and Einstein. ونحن بالطبع سنسعد كأي مواطن عربي إذا كانت هذه الإنجازات حقيقية. We, of course, be happy like any Arab citizen, whether these achievements are real. أما إذا كانت غير ذلك وكان الهدف However, if the other was the target
هو هذا الشكل الهابط من الأنتشار الأعلامى الذى ربما يكون بأجر مدفوع مسبقا. This form is downward from spreading Media, which may be paid pre-paid. وربما تتورط بعض المراكز البحثية على مستوى الوطن العربي فى مشاريع بحثية يروج لها د. Perhaps some research centers involved in the Arab world in research projects promoted by d. النشائى وليس له فيها أى باع يذكر. Alnchaiy and not sold any in which he mentioned. مما يؤدى إلى إهدار المال العام فيما لاطائل من Which leads to wastage of public money in the Atail of
ورائه وأن يتقدم الصفوف ممن لايحق له الصدارة ولاتؤهله مواهبه وإنجازاته لذلك. Behind them and move the rows of those who has no right to the forefront and Atwhlh talents and accomplishments of that. كل ما فى الأمر هو إنجازات وهمية صنعها هذا All of it is fake achievements and made this
الإنتشار الأعلامى الرخيص. Media proliferation of cheap. وليطلع أى منا إن شاء على أخر كتاب أصدره المفكر المصرى الراحل د. And to learn any of us willing, on the latest book by the late Egyptian thinker d. زكى نحيب محمود وهو حصاد Zaki Mahmoud, a wailing harvest
السنين فى أخر صفحة منه وهو يتحدث عن ظاهرة عملقة الأقزام فى مصر وهى تتم للأشخاص القريبين من وسائل الأعلام أو بعض Last Page of years in which he talked about the phenomenon of macrosomia dwarfs in Egypt, is for people who are close to the media or some
الجهات فى السلطة فتجد الشخص يصبح فى غمضة عين أديبا كبيرا وماهو بأديب أو عالما كبيرا وماهو بعالم. Those in power Vtjd person becomes a man of letters in the blink of an eye, and what a large granules or a scientist, and what a great world ["world" should be translated as "scientist"].

الدكتور النشائى ملأ وسائل الأعلام فى العالم العربي عن إنجازاته الهائلة فى مجال فيزياء الجسيمات الأولية ونظرياته الجديدة وتوحيد كل القوى الموجودة فى الطبيعة وحل كل المعضلات الفيزيائية وعلاوة على ذلك كونه خبيرا عالميا فى النانو تكنولوجي. Dr. Alnchaiy filled the media in the Arab world for its great achievements in the field of elementary particle physics and theories of new and unite all the forces existing in nature and solving all the problems of the physical Moreover, being a world expert in nanotechnology. وإذا كان النشائى لديه بحق كل هذه الإنجازات فهو بحق يستحق جائزة نوبل وتبوأ المكانة التى يستحقها فى كبريات الجامعات والمراكز البحثية ليس فى العالم العربي فقط ولكن على مستوى العالم. If Alnchaiy has the right to all of these accomplishments is truly deserves a Nobel Prize and has assumed its rightful place in leading universities and research centers not only in the Arab world, but in the world. ولكن هناك بعض الأشياء المثيرة للجدل والشبهات حول د. But there are some things controversial and suspicions about the d. النشائى Alnchaiy

1- الدكتور النشائى تقريبا ينشر معظم أبحاثه منفردا فى مجلة واحدة هى 1 - Dr. Alnchaiy almost alone most of his work published in the magazine and one is

http://www.elsevier.com/wps/find/journaldescription.cws_home/967/description#description
وهى مجلة يرأس تحريرها وهذا مايثير الشك, ولم ينشر أبدا مثلا فى Physical Review , A magazine edited by this something to doubt, for example, was never published in Physical Review
أو Nuclear Physics وهذه من المجلات المرموقة فى المجال الذى تخصص فيه د. Or Nuclear Physics This is one of the prestigious journals in the field, who majored in which d. النشائى وأبدع فيه إلا وهو فيزياء الجسيمات الأولية. Alnchaiy and excelled in it except the physics of elementary particles. وأيضا إذا أبحاثه بهذه الدرجة من الأهمية والثورية فيمكنه النشر أيضا بسهولة فى مجلة Nature أو Science Also, if research such an important and revolutionary it can also easily Published in the journal Nature or Science

ونحن نتعجب من كون الدكتور عطية عاشور عضو شرفى فى هيئة تحرير هذه المجلة وهو أحد العلماء المصريين الأجلاء. We marvel at the fact that Dr. Attia Ashour honorary member of the editorial board of this magazine, one of Egyptian scientists evacuation.

2- معدله فى إنتاج الأبحاث ضخم للغاية فهو تقريبا وخاصة فى الفترة الأخيرة أصبح ينشر بحثا يوميا منفردا وهذا لم يحدث فى تاريخ العلم ولكم زبارة الموقع التالى 2 - average in the production of research is very large, it is almost, especially in the recent period is published daily in search of solo, and this did not happen in the history of science and you Zabara the following website:
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleListURL&_method=list&_ArticleListID=747092979&_sort=d&view=c&_acct=C000019061&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=403633&md5=afaa18b9fc7770eb1bf016f971ca1b02
وكلها بالطبع منشورة فى مجلته. Of course, all published in his magazine.

3- عندما نبحث عن مرات الرجوع إلى أبحاثه فى قاعدة البيانات الخاصة بـ ستنافورد وهى متخصصة فى مجال د النشائى نجد تقريبا لايوجد أحد يرجع إليه إلا هو شخصيا أو بعض من ينشرون فى مجلته ولكم زيارة الموقع التالى فعدد مرات الرجوع إليه 33 ومعامل h يساوى 3 3 - When looking for the times refer to the research at the base of data for Stanford is specialized in the field of d Alnchaiy find almost no one is ascribed to him but he himself or some of the spread in the magazine and you visit the following website: The number of times referring to him 33 and a factor equal to 3 h
http://www.slac.stanford.edu/spires/find/hep/wwwcitesummary?rawcmd=find+a+el-naschie
ورؤية بعض المؤشرات الأخرى مثل معامل h And seeing some other indicators such as the coefficient h
http://www.slac.stanford.edu/spires/find/hep/www?rawcmd=FIND+a+el-naschie&format=wwwcitesummary2

العالم الفيزيائى الأمريكى الشهير إدوارد ويتن عدد مرات الرجوع إليه 81886 ومعامل h له يساوى 133 ولم يرشح لجائزة نوبل ولم يملأ الدنيا صياحا بإنجازاته. World famous American physicist Edward Witten, the number of times reference 81886 and a factor h is equal to 133 has not been nominated for the Nobel Prize did not fill the world with loud screams of his achievements. وعلاوة على ذلك العالم إدوارد ويتن يعتبر رياضيا مرموقا وحاصل على ميدالية فيلدس Fields Medal فى الرياضيات وهى مايعادل جائزة نوبل فى الفيزياء. In addition to that world Edward Witten is a remarkable athlete and was awarded the Fields Medal Fields Medal in mathematics equivalent of a Nobel Prize in physics.
http://www.slac.stanford.edu/spires/find/h...y&SEQUENCE=
ولعله من الطرافة بمكان أن د. It would be important to wit d. النشائى له بحث معنون بملاحظات على بعض النظريات الخاصة بنظرية M لويتن ... Alnchaiy his paper entitled observations on some theories about the theory of M Luyten ...
A few hints and some theorems about Witten's M theory and T-duality
ولكم الموقع And your site
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B6TJ4-4FR3N99-3&_user=2249840&_coverDate=08%2F31%2F2005&_alid=698135114&_rdoc=6&_fmt=summary&_orig=search&_cdi=5300&_sort=d&_docanchor=&view=c&_ct=8&_acct=C000056743&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=2249840&md5=1925b7b6e2e9f6f5a15592d42d7f22a2
وعندما تتصفح البحث ومراجعه لاتجد فيه أى رجوع لبحث مؤلف من طرف ويتن وهذه بحد ذاتها أعجوبة وأضحوكة فى عرف البحث العلمى. When you browse and search and review of the Atjd where any author Back to Search by Witten and this itself is a marvel and a mockery in the traditions of scientific research.

4- كونه خبيرا عالميا فى النانو تكنولوجى كيف يتأتى ذلك وهو ليس له إلا مقالة واحدة عن النانو تكنولوجى منشورة فى مجلته أيضا وهى مقالة تعد من قبيل العلم للعامة أو تبسيط العلوم (popular Science) 4 - being a world expert in nanotechnology is how can that has only one article on nanotechnology published in the magazine article which is also regarded as science to the public or popular science (popular Science)
Nanotechnology for the developing world Nanotechnology for the developing world
Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, Volume 30, Issue 4, November 2006, Pages 769-773 Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, Volume 30, Issue 4, November 2006, Pages 769-773
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleListURL&_method=list&_ArticleListID=718017353&_sort=d&view=c&_acct=C000052544&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=1723672&md5=8bfa890892c368dcba4504b35d3a2c9f

5- النشائى دائما يذكر فى وسائل الأعلام أنه كان أستاذا فى كمبيردج لمدة أحد عشر عاما من 1991 - 2002 والمثير للدهشه انه لم يذكر هذا فى صفحته الخاصة على الأنترنت 5 - Alnchaiy always mentioned in the media that he was a professor at Kmberdj [Cambridge] for a period of eleven years from 1991 to 2002 and the surprising he did not mention this in the special page on the Internet
http://www.el-naschie.net
ولكن عندما نبحث عنه نجد أن له بحثان سحبا من قاعدة البيانات الخاصة بفيزياء الطاقة العالية بسبب إنتحاله هذا العنوان ويمكن مراسلة جامعة كمبيردج للتأكد إن كان قد عمل أستاذا هناك أم لا وإليكم زيارة المواقع التالية لرؤية البحث المسحوب وأشياء أخرى But when we are looking for, we find that it has withdrawn Monographs of the database for high-energy physics because of the spoofed address, and can write to the University of Kmberdj to make sure that the professor had worked there or not, and you visit the following links to see the search withdrawn and other things
http://lanl.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0008056
http://lanl.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0004152
http://archivefreedom.org/freedom/Cyberia.html

6- مسألة تكريمه فى الصين ووضعه فى مصاف طبقة العلماء أمثال نيوتن وأينشتاين هذا التكريم تم من مجموعة غير متخصصة فى فيزياء الطاقات العالية وعلى رأسهم Ji-Huan He , 6 - the question of honor in China and put a layer in the ranks of scientists, such as Newton and Einstein were honoring the group that specialized in high-energy physics, led by Ji-Huan He,
فهم غير مؤهلين لتقييم إنجازات فى مجال فيزياء الجسيمات الأولية, They are not qualified to evaluate the achievements in the field of physics of elementary particles,
ونلاحظ أن Huan له مجلة International Journal of Nonlinear Sciences and Numerical Simulation يرأس تحريرها وينشر فيها د. We note that a magazine Huan International Journal of Nonlinear Sciences and Numerical Simulation as an editor and published by the d. النشائى و Huan أيضا ينشر فى مجلة د. Huan Alnchaiy and also published in the Journal d. النشائى. Alnchaiy. ولكم موقع التكريم And honor to your site

http://www.ijnsns.com/conf.html
ويمكن مراجعة بعض الجهات المعنية المتخصصة فى الصين للسؤال عن هذا التكريم مثل Can review some of the specialized agencies concerned in China to ask for this honor, such as
Institute of Theoretical Physics Institute of Theoretical Physics
Chinese Academy of Sciences Chinese Academy of Sciences
http://www.itp.ac.cn/eng/quantum.html

7- كيف يحدث فى بلد كبير مثل مصر أن يعين د. 7 - How does it happen in a large country such as Egypt to appoint d. النشائى مستشارا لوزير التعليم العالى الحالى فى مجال فيزياء الطاقات العالية والنانو تكنولوجى ويكيلون المديح للرجل فى الفضائيات المصرية (د. هانى هلال الوزير الحالى ود. عمرو سلامة -الوزير السابق-) إلايعرفون هذه الأشياء عن الرجل أم خدعوا أهذا هو مستوى وزراء التعليم العالى فى بلد عربى كبير مثل مصر. Alnchaiy advisor to the Minister of Higher Education in the field of current high-energy physics, nanotechnology, and praising the man in the Egyptian satellite (d. Hany Helal the incumbent minister, Dr.. Amr Salama - a former minister -) Ilaiarafon these things about the man or deceived Is this the level of ministers of higher education in a country a large Arab such as Egypt.
http://www.el-naschie.net

8- أن يعين الرجل أستاذا غير متفرغ فى عديد من الجامعات المصرية ويكون ذلك مقابل نشر أبحاث رديئة فى مجلته أهكذا يصل الحال بالجامعات فى أكبر دولة عربية مثل مصر. 8 - The man appointed professor emeritus in several Egyptian universities and be bad for publishing research in the journal like this how many universities in the largest Arab country like Egypt. وفى الواقع أن هذه المجلة أصبحت الملاذ الأخير لمن لايستطيع أن ينشر فى مجلة علمية In fact, this magazine has become the last resort for those who could not be published in a scientific journal
محترمة أو نصف محترمة. Respectable or semi-respectable. يكفى أن يكتب أى شيىء ثم يرجع إلى أبحاث د. Enough to write anything it and then return to research d. النشائى. Alnchaiy. أنه من الواجب شطب هذه المجلة على مستوى الوطن العربى من المجلات التى يعتد بها فى الترقيات العلمية وأن تهمل كل الأبحاث الت تنشر فى هذه المجلة. It must be written off this magazine in the Arab world of magazines that significant in promotions and that neglect of scientific research which Walt published in this magazine.

9- أن يملأ الرجل وسائل الأعلام المصرى بهذا الشكل الفج ويصرح فى برنامج خاص جدا عام 2007 على الفضائية المصرية بأنه أنجز أبحاثا تؤهله بجدارة لجائزة نوبل وأنه لاحرج عليه وأنه وضع أعضاء لجنة نوبل فى وضع محرج. 9 - to fill the men and the Egyptian media, so raw and state in a very special program in 2007 on the Egyptian satellite research that he had done deserved to qualify him for the Nobel Prize and that embarrassed him and he put the members of the Nobel committee in an embarrassing situation. حقا لقد وضع العرب كلهم فى وضع محرج. It has really put the Arabs, all in an embarrassing situation. وبرامج أخرى كثيرة مثل أسئل لدرية شرف الدين وحواراته مع الأديب الكبيرجما ل الغيطانى. And many other programs such as Ask the Doria Sharaf al-Din and his conversations with the writer for Kabergma Ghitani. ومجموعة من الصحفيين يدبجون المقالات عن عظمته وإنجازاته. And a group of journalists reported by articles on the greatness and achievements. أهكذا يصل مستوى الإعلام فى مصر أم أن هذه مقالات ومقابلات وحوارات مدفوعة الأجر مسبقا. This how you reach the level of information in Egypt or that these articles, interviews, conversations prepaid. قد يكون البعض مخدوعا مثل الأديب جمال الغيطانى وعذره أنه أديب ولكن يبدو أن البعض مأجورا. Some may be deceived such as writer Gamal al-Ghitani, then, he Adib, but it seems that some wage employment.

10- الدكتور النشائى مرشح دائم لجائزة نوبل حتى أن أحد الحاصلين عليها أقر انه لايستحقها وأنها ضلت طريقها بدلا من أن تعرف طريقها الصحيح إلى النشائى!!!!! 10 - Dr. Alnchaiy a permanent candidate for the Nobel Prize so that one who obtained it acknowledged that the Esthakha and it has lost its way, rather than to know the correct way to Alnchaiy !!!!! لا ندرى من أين يعرف بمثل هذه الأخبار و أنه رشح لجائزة نوبل أم لا. We do not know where to pick up on such news and that he was nominated for the Nobel Prize or not.

11- لماذا لاتتهافت الجامعات الكبرى مثل كمبيردج و كالتيك و أكسفورد و هارفارد ومعهد ماسيتوش للتقانة على د. 11 - Why Ataathavt Kmberdj major universities such as Caltech and Harvard, Oxford and the Institute of Technology Masitosh on d. النشائى وتنصبه أستاذا فيها بدلا من تغيير عنوانه من حين إلى أخر إلى إحدى الجامعات فى مصر. Alnchaiy and reinstalled a professor instead of changing the title from time to time to one of the universities in Egypt. ولماذا لايذهب إلى المحافل العلمية الهامة عن نظرية الأوتار أو التماثل الفائق وإلى الجامعات المذكورة سابقا ويلقى أبحاثه ومحاضراته لماذا يليقيها فقط فى مصر و بعض الأماكن فى الوطن العربى. Why did it Aivhb to the important scientific forums on string theory or super-symmetry and to the universities mentioned above and deliver research and lectures why Eliqiha only in Egypt, and some places in the Arab world.

12- د. 12 - d. النشائى يلمح ويصرح كثيرا عن نظرية المؤامرة وكيف أن الغرب يتجاهل أبحاثه ولايمنحه جائزة نوبل برغم أحقيته. Alnchaiy hints and declares a lot about the conspiracy theory and how the West ignored his work and Aymanha Nobel Prize, despite their eligibility. ولعل العكس قد يكون صحيحا وأنه هو جزء من المؤامرة ويصمت الغرب عن مثل هؤلاء الأشخاص بل من الممكن أن يرعاهم ويسمح لهم بعمل مجلات فى مؤسسات نشر عريقة وذلك لإفساد المناخ العلمى فى دولة كبيرة مثل مصر ومنه ينتشر إلى باقى المنطقة. Perhaps the opposite might be true and it is part of the conspiracy and the West remain silent about such people, but can be nurtured and allowed to work in magazines and corporate publishers long to corrupt the scientific environment in a big country such as Egypt and from there spread to the rest of the region. ولك أن تخيل You imagine that
أن المجلة الت كرمته فى الصين تنشر فى دار نشر موجودة فى إسرائيل ويمكنكم الأطلاع على الموقع التالى. Walt honored by the magazine in China, published in a publishing house located in Israel and can be seen on the following location.

http://www.ijnsns.com/publisher.html

13- لقد اندهشت عندما قرأت موقعا فى الأنترنت للعالم الكبير جبرارد توفت(Gerard 't Hooft) وهو حائز على جائزة نوبل فى الفيزياء عام 1999 وفى صفحته يتحدث عن كيف تصبح عالما فيزيائيا نظريا سيئا وإليكم الموقع 13 - I was surprised when I read the site on the Internet for the world of the large Jibrard died (Gerard 't Hooft), a Nobel laureate in physics in 1999 and in HomePage talking about how to become a world physically bad and you theoretically Site
http://www.phys.uu.nl/~thooft/theoristbad.html
للأسف الصفحة باللغة الأنجليزية ولمن عنده الوقت الكافى ليته يقوم بترجمتها. Unfortunately page in English and those who had enough time to wish I shall translate. وعند قراءة هذه الصفحة يتبين مدى التطابق الشديد بين معايير توفت للفيزيائى النظرى السييء ومايتصف به د. When you read this page shows how strong congruence between the criteria of theoretical physicist died of poor play and his Maitcef d. النشائى. Alnchaiy. وهذا التطابق الشديد يوحى كأن توفت يعرف النشائى ويصفه ولايسميه. This congruence suggests he was a great died Alnchaiy know, calls the Aisemeh.

أليس فى مصر علماء فى الفيزياء يستطيعون الحكم وتقييم أعمال النشائى وإعطائه حقه أو إيقافه عند حده. Alice in Egypt in physics, scientists can assess the work of governance and Alnchaiy and give it right or keep it at bay. إن الحكم على أعماله أمر ميسور فمجرد الأطلاع على عناوين أبحاثه وملخصاتها لتكتشف الحقيقة. The verdict on his work is easy mere learning of the addresses research and summaries to discover the truth. فلكى تدرك ملوحة ماء البحر لايستدعى أن تشرب البحر كله ولكن يكفى تذوق قطرة واحدة. Astronomical aware of desalination of sea water to Aestday to drink the whole sea, but enough taste one drop. وأخيرا فى زمن الأنكسار والهزائم والإحباط تلتف الناس حول أى بطل حتى لو كان زائفا. Finally, in the time of refracting and defeats and frustrations of people around the loop any hero even if it is false.
إن ما قيل هو من منطلق الغيرة على بلد عربى كبير مثل مصر معطاءة وولادة بالنجباء وستظل منارة للعالم العربى. What was said is out of jealousy for a large Arab country such as Egypt and the birth of affordable Bnagaba and will remain a beacon for the Arab world. لكن ينبغى التأكد من هذه المعلومات وأعطاء كل ذى حق حقه. But you should make sure this information and to give everyone his rights. وعلى الصحفيين والأعلاميين إذا تبينوا أنهم كانوا مخدوعين ولبسوا مأجورين أن يصححوا مواقفهم تجاه ذلك الرجل. Journalists and news media indicate if they were deceived and wore hired to correct their attitudes toward the man. إننا فى عصر أصبح من الممكن التأكد من أية معلومات عن طريق الأنترنت وأستخدام محركات البحث مثل Google وهذا أمر ميسور لقطاع كبير من الناس وخصوصا المشتغلين فى مجال الإعلام والعلم. We are in the era it became possible to make sure any information through the Internet and use search engines such as Google and this is easy for a large sector of people, especially workers in the field of information and knowledge.

إن الهدف كما قلت مسبقا هو معرفة الحقيقة, ومن عنده كلام أودلة أخرى تناقض هذا فليأتى به وسنكون من السعداء إذا ثبت عكس The goal, as I said previously is to know the truth, and he has Oodlp other words contrary to this Vlioty him and we'll be happy if proven to
ماذكرناه. Mazkrnah. ومعذرة فالمقال طويل وبه تفاصيل فنية لأننا نود أن يساهم المتخصصين فى هذا الحوار والنقاش Extremes Valmqal long connotations of the technical details, we would like to contribute to specialists in this dialogue and debate

Old 29-05-2008, 11:03 PM 29-05-2008, 11:03 PM
Scorpion300


Reply: The Truth About Dr. Alnchaiy

السيد المدعو / الشيشتاوى Mr. invitee / Alcesthaoy
السبب الرئيسى فى اعتقادى أن الدكتور محمد صلاح الدين النشائى لا يرد على سيادتكم هو اولاً انها صادره من شخص متخفى وراء اسم مستعار و ان اسم شخصكم الحقيقى هو سعيد اما اسم عائلاتكم فأنا لن اذكره رأفه بوالديك الذين ليس لهم اى ذنب فى اخلاقك . The main reason I believe that Dr. Mohamed Salah El-Din Alnchaiy not respond to you is first that it comes from someone invisible behind a pseudonym and that the real name of your person is either the name of your family happy ["said" means happy, so this is a mistranslation. It's Said's name.], I will not mention it to your parents mercy, who have no guilt in morals. فنحن نعلم تمام العلم انه حكم على سيادتكم من عدة اشهر فى محكمة جنايات الجيزة بالسجن لمدة عام مع ايقاف التنفيذ بسبب سنكم الذى جاوز الستين ورأفه بماضيكم ونعرف تماماً انكم مصابون بمرض انفصام الشخصية ولو كنتم فى دولة أوربية لحكم عليكم بالبرائه وتم ايداعكم فقط فى مصحه للعلاج و نعلم ان السيدة المسئوله عن الجريمة حكم عليها بالسجن سنتان مع الحبس المشدد و الاشغال و قد قضت منهم ثمانى شهور فى سجن القناطر للنساء بعد أن ظلت هاربه لمدة عام بالساحل الشمالى وتقوم هذه السيدة باستخدام جنابكم للانتقام من من تظنه مسئولاً فى القبض عليها . We know full well that was sentenced to you by several months in the Giza Criminal Court sentenced to one year suspended sentence because of your age, which exceeded sixty Bmadikm mercy, and we know you are suffering from schizophrenia, had you in a European country to the rule you Aidaekm acquittal was only in the clinic for treatment and We know that the woman responsible for the crime, was sentenced to two years rigorous imprisonment with hard and decided that it has in eight months in prison barrages of women after having been a fugitive in the northern coast and is using this lady Jnabkm to avenge Who do u think is responsible to arrest them. كل ادعائتكم فى حق الدكتور محمد صلاح الدين النشائى ما هى الا اكاذيب و افترائات صادرة عن حقد جنونى و غيرة قاتلة وهذا واضح لكل قارئ وضوح الشمس مما تكتبون . All in the right Adeaitkm Dr. Mohamed Salah El-Din Alnchaiy, is just lies and fabrications issued by the insane hatred and jealousy of fatal and this is clear for each reader and crystal, which you write. والشخص الذى يعترف فى خطاب مفتوح بأنه تقاعد و عاد من الولايات المتحدة خصيصا ليسخر ما تبقى له من حياة فى ايذاء و تحطيم صورة الاستاذ الدكتور / محمد النشائى و مستعد ان يتعاون فى ذلك مع خونة و صهاينة ، هو شخص يفتقد لاى نوع من احترام النفس و اى نوع من الخلاق ، ولكن المريض حجته معه . The person who is recognized in an open letter that he retired and returned from the United States specifically to mock the rest of his life to hurt and destroy the image of Prof. Dr. / Mohamed Alnchaiy and ready to cooperate with the traitors and the Zionists, is a person who lacks any kind of self-esteem and any kind of creative, but the patient argument with him.
صورة سيادتكم وراء القضبان و صورة الحكم الصادر ضدكم يمكننا نشره على هذا الموقع وليس فى ذلك اى اشكال ولكن نربأ بأنفسنا من الانزلاق إالى هذا المستوى فى الوقت الحالى ، كما نعلم تمام العلم ان حولكم شرذمة من الطلاب والاساتذة الفاشلين الذين يساعدونكم لقاء ملاليم فى هذه الاعمال المخزية و الكتابات التافها التى تضيعون وقتكم و وقت الاخرين فيها . Image you behind bars and a ruling against you, we published on this site, and there's no problem, but Nrbo ourselves from slipping grown to this level at present, as is well known that around you a handful of students and professors losers who assist you to meet pennies in these shameful acts Altavha and writings, which are wasting your time and the time of others.
الدكتور النشائى يعمل بمبدا ان احسن اجابة على السفهاء هى السكوت وكل هذه الاكاذيب و السموم النابعة من الحقد و الجهل و الرغبة فى الانتقام التى تبثوها تعود فى النهاية إلى مصدرها كما حدث لك من قبل . Dr. Alnchaiy works on the basis that the best answer to fools is silence all these lies and poisons emanating from ignorance, hatred and desire for vengeance that Tbutoha to return at the end to their source, as has happened to you before. لقد قضيت على مستقبلك وعلى سمعتك بنفسك والان لم يتبقى لكم سوى تكريس حياتك التى لا ترى من ورائها اى طائل سوى إيذاء الاخرين عن طريق انتحال شخصيات وهمية مثل العربى و فرج على و خلافه وارسال خطابات كاذبة تتسم بالندالة و الخسة تشهد عليها كلماتك و يشهد عليها كل من يعرفك معرفه حقيقية . I have spent on your future and your reputation for yourself and now you are left only to devote your life that does not see from behind, but any unnecessary harm to others by impersonating imaginary characters such as the Arab and Faraj and etc. and send letters Balndalp are false and the evidence of your vile and witnessed by all who know you know the real.

Old 31-05-2008, 06:05 PM 31-05-2008, 06:05 PM
Scorpion300


Said,
I am ashamed for you because you have lost the sense of shame and you are disgracing yourself, your family, Egypt, Saudi Arabia and the entire Arab world. So now you are calling yourself Meshmesh. Why not call yourself Shadia or Chechita banana or was it Chechany banana? My memory is fading. [Chiquita Banana. Making fun of Shadia Al-Shishini's name. That's a bit childish. She's the second wife of Said Elnaschaie, and is the mother of Jihan fadel by an earlier marriage.]
I remember when I was picking you up from Riyadh airport [This is a clue to the real-life identity of scorpion300 and his many other aliases.] when you were coming from abroad and you spent an hour in the car praising Prof. Mohamed Al Nashaie and how much he has done for you and how much he has done for your ungrateful wife - what a genius he is and how powerful and well-connected and how much proud you are of having such a connection to such a great man. You might remember that you brought me, in one of these trips from London, a shoe as a present. Politeness prevents me from saying what I would like to do with the shoes.
You have betrayed even your respectable past – even as a communist and a socialist you are becoming a disgrace. Without Professor Mohamed Salah El Din Al Nashaie or El Naschie as he is internationally known, you would have disappeared from the face of the earth. You were sick and penniless- he took you and sent you for medical care in London and kept the secret of your mental illness to himself and risked taking the responsibility of sending someone like you to Saudi Arabia. You forgot all that. It was tragic to see you behind bars. But this is not Prof. Mohamed Al Nashaie’s mistake. Your wife brought it on you – she and her greedy daughter. She had to produce films even if it is on the account that you steal your own mother. Then you stage this comedy worried about theoretical physics in Egypt. What do you know about physics - theoretical or otherwise? You were a good engineer and a good teacher and once upon a time a good friend. I don’t agree with Prof. Mohamed Al Naschie that this is all the schizophrenia you are suffering from. The wickedness with which you plan all these defamation campaigns and the shamelessness with which you execute your plans involving Nobel laureate Ahmed Zewail and not even shrugging from playing a Zionist card to make cheap attacks against a man to whom you owe everything.
Prof. El Naschie sat beside me and was tormented by you standing behind bar. I have known you for a long time Said and I have witnessed this tragedy and your path towards self-destruction from the beginning - 9 years ago. You don’t convince me of anything and you have no excuse and not even schizophrenia. You know very well how two particularly famous scientists in Arabia are jealous of Mohamed. I will name only one – the Palestinian who is dying to get a prize even if he allies himself with the Zionists. The other made in the USA and everybody knows and nobody cares about him. But you have been the most destructive tool in the hands of the Zionists and recalling your past and courageous struggle against Zionism to turn you against your own friend and more. Show me that this was only vanity. You have never been a national hero. You are a vain man and extremely wicked who doesn’t shrug from stealing his own mother and slandering his family.
I will not sign this letter with my real name to give you a minimal protection. Because if I sign it everybody will know exactly who you are and Prof. El Naschie despite all what you have done, still doesn’t like to expose you more than you have exposed yourself already.
Helal Lotfi

31-05-2008, 07:26 PM 31-05-2008, 07:26 PM
Scorpion300


Reply: The Truth About Dr. Alnchaiy

السيد المحترم /الششتاوى Dear Mr. / الششتاوى
لقد ارسلت سمومك الان خارج حدود مصر ولا تريد انت تقف عند حدك ولا تتقى الله فى افترائاتك المشينة ولذلك لا باس من ذكر اسمك الحقيقى وهو سعيد صلاح حامد استاذ الجامعة المهندس الدكتور الذى حكم عليه بالسجن لانه كما قال هو بنفسه فى محكمة الحاسبى انه يفضل انه يكون لص و مزور على ان يكون مريض بمرض انفصام الشخصية . I sent Smomk far outside the borders of Egypt does not want you stand alone when you do not fear God in Afteraiatk shameful and no harm to mention your real name, Saeed Hamid Salah university professor, Dr. Eng, who was sentenced because he is as he said himself in the computerized court that he would prefer that he be a thief and forger to be patient schizophrenia.
اما السيدة شادية التى لم يكفيها ما قضته فى سجن السيدات فى القناطر و الان تريد ان تشعل العالم كله حريق تحت اسماء مستعارة مثل ابن مصر و العربى و صحيح ان من يقوم بالاعمال فى مستوى الاعمال التى قامت بها لا تعرف كلمة الحياء ولا الخلق. Ms Shadia, which is not enough spent in the prison of women in the Vaults and now wants to ignite the fire the whole world under aliases such as Egypt and the Arab son, and is true that the charge d'affaires in the level of work carried out by do not know the word modesty and manners. ولن تسطتيع الممثلة الفاشلة انتزاع كلاكم هذه المرة من قبضة القانون ونحن نعدكم بذلك . Representative will Tsttie Clakm failed to extract, this time from the grip of the law and we promise to do so.

01-06-2008, 02:01 PM
elsheshtwi


Really, you are proving for me now that you ar El Naschie himself. From your reply, you are proving that never worked in science. If you are a scientist you will reply by scientific proof which can convince the scienist about your work. Why you didnot clearfy the points that is mentioned in my article about you. Why you didnot explain why the your papers has been withdrawn as apunishment for our scandal that you claimed you are working at Cambridge University while Cambridge University complained that you never worked there. If you are real scientist, why the other scientist dinot take you as a reference. I am really ashamed of you.
also i am not this guy that you are talking about who is caled said. I am one who is hating very much the liars like you and want to show your eality for the people. I promise you that these information will be spreaded to all the media

01-06-2008, 05:35 PM
elsheshtwi


Dear Mr. El Naschie [Elsheshtwi is mistaken. Scorpion300 isn't El Naschie.]

Since you didn't get even B.Sc in Physics [I think elsheshtwi is correct here. El Naschie doesn't even have an undergraduate degree in physics.], i don't know what i should call you.
You insulted some person called said and you claimed that i am himself. Really i am not that guy that you are speaking about. It seems that you can't even distinguish.
I am just one student who interest to know your reality. Really i was very happy when i knew that there is Egyptian one working is High energy Physics, but really i ashamed of you. Please tell me who told you that you nominated for Nobel Prize. You should disappear because all the real scientists abroad considering that you are very bad example for the Egyptian scientists outside Egypt. Really you cause a lot of bad things for Egypt although you are speaking about introducing science for Egypt. Please convince me how you can introduce something that you don't have it.""FAKED EL SHEAA LA YOTIAH""
Please disappear from that media which introduced you to the people without even investigating about your bad career in the science. ARXIV punished you that you can't submit any paper to it because you claimed wrong affiliation. [Correct. El Naschie is banned from publishing on arXiv for affiliational arrogation.] Cambridge Complained for Arxiv that you never worked at Cambridge University. [And he keeps on claiming Cambridge affiliation even today, in the Arab media.] You don't have any citation from any scientist. No one interest in what you are doing. see your citation on spires and you will find this scandal. I can forget everything and i promise you to not publish any article about you through the INTERNET if you can publish only one paper ( just one paper ) in Physical Review or Nature .

Finally, i was laughing very much when i saw your funny replies in the INTERNET which confirmed for me you never worked in science

01-06-2008, 09:00 PM
Scorpion300

You are a bunch of hired cowards and you are nothing but Said Salah El Din Hamed who has been kicked out of the University in America and now you are jobless spending your meaningless life trying to defame and slander people who are better than him in every respect. A man melting with hatred and jealousy. You are not worth talking to or answering and in all honesty you represent nothing. If you have any dignity and of any value you wouldnt do what you are doing. Dr. Said go on slandering as much as you want and you stood behind bar, a pathetic liar and a thief and you have been convicted for one year imprisonment and now all what you are doing to your friends, relatives and countrymen inventing silly little nutter who is supposed to be a student of physics. You can and your student and all the pseudo names you have been hiding behind in the last 9 years all go to hell. You are a madman and a schizophrenic and a man who stole his mother and all is documented in court papers which can be sent to this site. You can go on doing the only thing you are good at such as lying, cheating calling yourself once Shestwy, another time Al arabi, mesmesh, son o f Egypt . If you are a man and you are none, you wouldnt have left your wife Shadia go to prison in Al Qanater while you are hiding away like a little rat which you are. You are an aberration of creation. A birth mistake. A misconstructed ugly character that is impossible to describe. You with all your pseudo names create nausea in us

01-06-2008, 09:25 PM
Scorpion300


Reply: The Truth About Dr. Alnchaiy

هذا ما يقضى الفيزيائيين العرب عليه. This is what physicists Arabs spend it.
ما هو تعليمك يا دكتور سعيد صلاح حامد انت مهندس كميائى وطردت من جامعة العين و وبلاغت عنك جامعة البترول فى ارمكوا انك هربت ببدل السكن إلى الولايات المتحدة والان طردت من جامعتك فى الولايات المتحدة بسبب الحكم عليك بالتزوير لمدة سنة سجن و بسبب سنك تركوك !! What is your education, Dr. Said Salah Hamid Kamiaiy You are an engineer and expelled from the University of the eye, and you Blagt University of Petroleum in Armkua housing allowance to be smuggled to the United States and now expelled from the university in the United States by the verdict, you fraud for years in prison and because of your age Trkk!! الحكم جاء متاخر عشرات السنين لانه سبق ان سرقت اموال الجمعية التعاونية فى جامعة القاهرة و فصلت من جامعة القاهرة و مع ذلك لا تتعظ و سوف ترد كل اكاذيبك اليك . Ruling came late for decades he had already stolen the money of the cooperative at Cairo University and suspended from the University of Cairo, however, does not heed the warnings and all your lies will respond to you. انت وصمة عار للنفسك و لعائلتك ولمصر و العالم العربى كله . You are a disgrace to yourself and your family and Egypt and the Arab world as a whole. سمى نفسك الششيتاوى سمى نفسك الشيشينى الناس جميعا فى مصر يعرفوانك ويعرفوا سفالتك و جبنك ولو كنت رجل لما تركت شيريكتك فى الجريمة تدخل سجن القناطر و بقيت انت كالفار متخبئ فى الولايات المتحدة . Named yourself Alchetaoy named yourself Shishini all the people in Egypt and know Iarafwank Svaltk Jpennek and if you are a man to the left Hiriktk intervention in crime and prison vaults mousey Mtakbi you stay in the United States. وبعد 9 سنوات رجعت لمصر وتمثل النقد العلمى لماذا لا تركز على خبتك السوده و تترك الناس فى حالها صحيح ان اليوم الذى خلقك الله بدون خلفه كان يعلم تماما انك ليس رجل ولذلك راى ان لا يكثر من امثالك على وجه الارض لن ارد عليك بعد الان ايها الكلب المسعور فهوهو كما تريد ومن يصدقك سفالتك و اكاذيبك فهو مثلك والحمد لله لم يخلق الله من امثالك كثيرين. After 9 years, returned to Egypt and represents scientific Monetary Why not focus on Kpetk El Soda and leaves people in the same is true that the day that God created you without a successor was well aware you are not a man Therefore, it was not a lot of likes on earth would you question anymore, you dog Vhoho mad as you want, and believe you and your lies Svaltk is like you, thank God, God did not create many like you.

01-06-2008, 10:29 PM
elsheshtwi


Really, i donot know what i can say for you.
I am not this guy who called said. Why you can't understand. Really you are very stupied. Please, if you want to please reply by scientific proof. defend about yourself, why you are changing the subject into nothing, you are now accused by scientific scandals which can be confirmed from any scientist in physics, so if you like to defend about yourself, reply by scientific proof. I am not really this said who you are speaking about. Really, i am so happy becasue you are replying by that bad level of reply. really you never worked in science

Old 01-06-2008, 11:19 PM 01-06-2008, 11:19 PM
الجميلي Jumaili
[uh oh]

رد: حقيقة الدكتور النشائى Reply: The Truth About Dr. Alnchaiy

يغلق الموضوع لأنه نزل إلى مستوى لا يليق بأعضاء هذا الملتقى أن يقرؤه Closing theme because it came down to a level befitting the members of this forum should be read [Referee calls match citing unsportsmanlike conduct by both sides. Bad referee!]

أخي / Scorpion300 Brother / Scorpion300
أخي / elsheshtwi Brother / elsheshtwi

إن تكرر هذا الموضوع فسوف لن يكون لكم مكان هنا .... The recurrence of this issue, you will not have you around here .... [Threatening a permanent ban!]

Translate English to Arabic


محمد النشائى El Naschie Watch محمد النشائي El Naschie News محمد النشائى
محمد النشائي All El Naschie All The Time محمد النشائى

StumbleUpon.com

1 comment:

  1. Thank you very much for that support your showed for my campaign against that BIG liar Elnaschie.
    The last thing i heard about him that he want to run for presidency, hahaha, I sent my letters that you know to Hala Sarhaan, and many other talk show programs to inform them about his fraud, but unfortunately i did not receive any comment from them. In any case, As Elnaschie is in the media, i am following his BIG ass to kick it as much as i can, hahahah.

    My Best Greetings,

    Elsheshtwi

    ReplyDelete