Thursday, August 26, 2010

El Naschie's blacklisting from the arXiv

The purpose of this page is to collect information about the Michael Green vs Mohamed El Naschie incident of September 2000. If we learn more we will update it. The story, in short, is that El Naschie took advantage of the friendship or acquaintanceship with Sir Hermann Bondi, Master of Churchill College, Cambridge, and Prof. David Crighton FRS at the Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics (DAMTP) at Cambridge, by claiming for years to be affiliated with DAMTP. He used the fake affiliation to submit papers to the arXiv. Prof. Michael Green of DAMTP became annoyed, and got El Naschie blacklisted.


Carlos Castro Perelman is known to El Naschie Watch readers from his Cyberia page, whose title is a pun about being banished to Siberia. Mostly his story is about his outrage about his own banishment from the arXiv. We are interested in it because it tells about how El Naschie got banned from the arXiv. The relevant Cyberia passages are these:




...Jorge Mahecha e-mailed me telling me that Ginsparg had written an ultimatum giving us a two-day period to remove the fraudulent Cambridge affiliation from one of our other co-authors, M.S. El Naschie, chief Editor of the Journal of Chaos, Solitons and Fractals. Apparently Ginsparg received a complaint from Cambridge University (later I found out that it was Michael Green). Since Jorge Mahecha had only two days, he had no choice but to comply and removed the El Naschie's Cambridge affiliation without being able to make a thorough inquiry as to the veracity of the horrible allegations against M.S El Naschie. Shortly after, Jorge Mahecha opted to remove the paper altogether to avoid any further problems, before we had an opportunity to perform an investigation of the veracity of the serious charges raised by Michael Green (at Cambridge University) against M. S. El Naschie.

Having described the chain events in late January 2000 (the NPB fiasco), the subsequent removal of my papers to the hep-th category in early February 2000, and afterwards, the El Naschie-Michael Green incident in late August 2000, which I will analyze in further detail shortly, I will now reveal a personal e-mail written by Ginsparg himself to Fred Cooper at Los Alamos which is full of insults, lies and threats.

[...text unrelated to El Naschie omitted...]

2. The Insults, Multi-Layered Lies and Threats from Ginsparg

2.1 The Actual e-mail from Ginsparg to Fred Cooper at Los Alamos

Date: Fri, 29 Sep 2000 13:47:02 -0600 (MDT)
From: Paul Ginsparg ginsparg@lanl.gov
To: fcooper@physics.bc.edu
CC: simeon@mmm.lanl.gov, schwander@horse.lanl.gov
Subject: Re: Castro Clarification

a) castro is an obvious nut and all of his papers are abject nonsense

b) castro had a paper with a co-author [El Naschie] whose affiliation was forged as DAMTP (Cambridge), and we received a complaint directly from DAMTP. he was given a deadline to correct or remove the affiliation, or lose submission privileges. he CHOSE not to comply.


[...text unrelated to El Naschie omitted...]

2.2 The Analysis of the Multi-Layered Lies and Threats from Ginsparg

Ginsparg began to remove my papers in the hep-th archive-category in February 2000, six months prior to the El Naschie-Michael Green incident. Ginsparg concealed this fact from Fred Cooper by making me look as the "bad guy". The El Naschie-Michael Green incident was nothing but a diversion from the truth. Truth that Ginsparg did not wish to reveal to his boss, Fred Cooper.

In addition, Ginsparg accused me of having posted a paper with a false institutional affiliation by one of my colleagues, M. S. EL Naschie who is the chief editor of the Journal of Chaos, Solitons, and Fractals (CSF) published by Elsevier. However, the truth of the matter is that M. S. El Naschie had listed his affiliation, for many years, and at many public conferences, etc....., as DAMTP - Cambridge. I had no knowledge whatsoever that M. S. El Naschie was not permitted to use the Cambridge affiliation. How could I have known this before hand, if the affiliation of M. S. El Naschie was appearing in the CSF journal, and in many conferences.... was listed as DAMTP-Cambridge for many years? Why am I to blame?

Frank (Tony) Smith, a lawyer, scientist and another blacklistee wisely asked: Why wasn't Elsevier Science Publishers in Holland attacked by Cambridge University? Why weren't the organizers of the many public conferences where M.S El Naschie attended not attacked? ..... When, during all these years M. S. El Naschie was using the Cambridge affiliation?

Jorge Mahecha (from the ICTP in Trieste, Italy) removed the false institutional affiliation of M.S. El Naschie from our paper submitted to the e-archive within the two day deadline demanded by Ginsparg. Shortly after, within a period of 8 days, Jorge Mahecha removed the paper altogether. Since I was traveling in France and Spain during that time, Ginsparg lied when he accuse me of "choosing not to comply " after his ultimatum. Jorge Mahecha who was in Trieste, Italy to receive Ginsparg's e-mail-ultimatum did comply.

Alex Granik and Jorge Mahecha were among the co-authors of two papers with M.S. El Naschie and myself. Nevertheless, Alex Granik (University of the Pacific, Stockton, California) and Jorge Mahecha (University of Antioquia, Medellin, Colombia) have not been blacklisted by Ginsparg. They are permitted to post their papers to any category of the arXiv.org without any problems.

Why did M.S. El Naschie illicitly used the DAMTP-Cambridge affiliation for many years? It seems that because he was a friend of the former Head of the Physics Dept [referring to Prof. David Crighton FRS. see below] in Cambridge University that he took certain liberties for many years. After the El Naschie-Michael Green incident took place, he is no longer using the DAMTP-Cambridge affiliation...




Zahy points to an amusing March 23 comment from Alexander Donnelly, which we quote here in part:

Nonetheless, his work caused a stir and forced him to leave Cambridge after the death of his friend Prof. David Crighton FRS, the Head of DAMPT [sic] and subsequent departure of his teacher and mentor who brought him to Cambridge in the first place, Sir Herman Bondi who together with Gold and Hoile [sic. Hoyle] were the pioneers of the cosmological steady state theory.


Carlos Castro Perelman has also published the text from which this is excerpted as a book:

Against the Tide, A Critical Review by Scientists of How Physics and Astronomy Get Done
Authors: Martín López Corredoira, Carlos Castro Perelman
Publisher: Universal Pub
Published Date: 2008-03
ISBN-10: 1599429934
ISBN-13: 9781599429939

UPDATE: A reader forwarded this email:

From: Garnet Ord <gord@acs.ryerson.ca>
Subject: non-e removal
Date: April 17, 2003 12:38:20 AM EDT

My colleague El Naschie has had the article hep-th/0004152 published in the ArXive [sic] without his consent. Although he is listed as co-author, he had no part in it. He has asked the author in question to remove the paper but to no avail. My colleague does not use the internet or email and so has no means to contact directly. For confirmation, his home address is :

Dr. Mohamed El Naschie,
3 Towngate,
Cobham, Surrey,
England, KT112TS.

***************************************
Garnet Ord http://www.scs.ryerson.ca/~gord/
Dept. of Math Physics and Comp. Sci.
Ryerson University
Toronto, Ont. M5K25B Canada
***************************************


See El Naschie's house in Surrey has been found!

Translate English to Arabic
محمد النشائى El Naschie Watch محمد النشائي El Naschie News محمد النشائى محمد النشائي All El Naschie All The Time محمد النشائى
StumbleUpon.com

15 comments:

  1. I think the person who enabled El naschie to use (DAMTP) as his affiliation is David George Crighton http://www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/about/dgc/

    Crighton was the head of DAMTP for the period 1991-2000, which is exactly the same period during which the great man used (DAMTP) as his affiliation.

    Crighton was working on the field of fluid mechanics, and maybe it was easy for the great man to deceive him, I guess that for the best scenario. Especially Crighton was a kind man, who always was quoted by `most people can do something well if they put their minds and energies to it'

    ReplyDelete
  2. You will find Crighton mentioned in
    http://elnaschiewatch.blogspot.com/2009/06/another-archive-for-your-amusement.html
    "....his work caused a stir and forced him to leave Cambridge after the death of his friend Prof. David Crighton FRS, the Head of DAMPT and subsequent departure of his teacher and mentor..."

    ReplyDelete
  3. You are absolutely right. Fixed.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Zahy, I think speculation on Crighton's kindness or credulity is unwarranted here. There are plenty of reasons for the head of something as large and ego-filled as DAMTP not to know the fine details of who does or doesn't have some affiliation.

    Also, MSelN may not be the most reliable source on whether Crighton had any friendship with or mentoring over MSelN. If there is any other external evidence for backing this up, it would be preferable to add this to the post.

    ReplyDelete
  5. "Also, MSelN may not be the most reliable source on whether Crighton had any friendship with or mentoring over MSelN."

    Yemon, that is true. The prominent figures El Naschie name-drops as his friends, acquaintances and mentors are usually dead and unable to demur.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yemon Choi, you are right and as I said my guess is based on assuming the best best scenario.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This used to be seen on the Smith or Castro site, but came off.
    It means even The Naschie has a standard. From E-infinity

    From: Garnet Ord
    Subject: non-e removal
    Date: April 17, 2003 12:38:20 AM EDT

    My colleague El Naschie has had the article hep-th/0004152 published in the
    ArXive without his consent.
    Although he is listed as co-author, he had no part in it.
    He has asked the author in question to remove the paper but to no avail.
    My colleague does not use the internet or email and so has no means to contact
    directly.
    For confirmation, his home address is :

    Dr. Mohamed El Naschie,
    3 Towngate,
    Cobham, Surrey,
    England, KT112TS.

    **************************************************************************
    Garnet Ord Phone 416-979-5000 ext 6967
    Dept. of Math Physics and Comp. Sci. email gord@acs.ryerson.ca
    Ryerson University fax 416-979-5343
    Toronto, Ont. M5K25B Home Page
    Canada http://www.scs.ryerson.ca/~gord/
    **************************************************************************

    ReplyDelete
  8. This used to be seen on the Smith or Castro site, but came off.
    It means even The Naschie has a standard. From E-infinity

    From: Garnet Ord
    Subject: non-e removal
    Date: April 17, 2003 12:38:20 AM EDT

    My colleague El Naschie has had the article hep-th/0004152 published in the
    ArXive without his consent.
    Although he is listed as co-author, he had no part in it.
    He has asked the author in question to remove the paper but to no avail.
    My colleague does not use the internet or email and so has no means to contact
    directly.
    For confirmation, his home address is :

    Dr. Mohamed El Naschie,
    3 Towngate,
    Cobham, Surrey,
    England, KT112TS.

    **************************************************************
    Garnet Ord http://www.scs.ryerson.ca/~gord/
    Dept. of Math Physics and Comp. Sci.
    Ryerson University
    Toronto, Ont. M5K25B Canada

    ReplyDelete
  9. This used to be seen on the Smith or Castro site, but came off.
    It means even The Naschie has a standard. From E-infinity

    From: Garnet Ord
    Subject: non-e removal
    Date: April 17, 2003 12:38:20 AM EDT

    My colleague El Naschie has had the article hep-th/0004152 published in the ArXive without his consent.
    Although he is listed as co-author, he had no part in it.
    He has asked the author in question to remove the paper but to no avail.
    My colleague does not use the internet or email and so has no means to contact directly.
    For confirmation, his home address is :

    Dr. Mohamed El Naschie,
    3 Towngate,
    Cobham, Surrey,
    England, KT112TS.

    ------------------------------------------------
    Garnet Ord http://www.scs.ryerson.ca/~gord/
    Dept. of Math Physics and Comp. Sci.
    Ryerson University
    Toronto, Ont. M5K25B Canada

    ReplyDelete
  10. This used to be seen on the Smith or Castro site, but came off.
    It means even The Naschie has a standard. From E-infinity

    From: Garnet Ord <gord@acs.ryerson.ca&rt;
    Subject: non-e removal
    Date: April 17, 2003 12:38:20 AM EDT

    My colleague El Naschie has had the article hep-th/0004152 published in the ArXive without his consent.
    Although he is listed as co-author, he had no part in it.
    He has asked the author in question to remove the paper but to no avail.
    My colleague does not use the internet or email and so has no means to contact directly.
    For confirmation, his home address is :

    Dr. Mohamed El Naschie,
    3 Towngate,
    Cobham, Surrey,
    England, KT112TS.

    -----------------------------------------------
    Garnet Ord   http://www.scs.ryerson.ca/~gord/
    Dept. of Math Physics and Comp. Sci.
    Ryerson University
    Toronto, Ont. M5K25B Canada

    ReplyDelete
  11. This used to be seen on the Smith or Castro site, but came off.
    It means even The Naschie has a standard. From E-infinity

    From: Garnet Ord <gord@acs.ryerson.ca>
    Subject: non-e removal
    Date: April 17, 2003 12:38:20 AM EDT

    My colleague El Naschie has had the article hep-th/0004152 published in the ArXive without his consent.
    Although he is listed as co-author, he had no part in it.
    He has asked the author in question to remove the paper but to no avail.
    My colleague does not use the internet or email and so has no means to contact directly.
    For confirmation, his home address is :

    Dr. Mohamed El Naschie,
    3 Towngate,
    Cobham, Surrey,
    England, KT112TS.

    ------------------------------
    Garnet Ord    http://www.scs.ryerson.ca/~gord/
    Dept. of Math Physics and Comp. Sci.
    Ryerson University
    Toronto, Ont. M5K25B Canada

    ReplyDelete
  12. And you apparently received this message on 15 sep, but it was apparently first attempted on 28 Aug (explaining the later "blogsite repeatedly deletes the attempted comment")

    ReplyDelete
  13. Wow. They attempted to tip us off several times, and the spam filter kept smacking them down.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Carlos Castro PerelmanJanuary 11, 2011 at 5:52 AM

    Am I to blame for having Mohammed El Naschie used illictly the Cambridge DAMTP affiliation for years ?

    To Garnet (Ord) : Jorge Mahecha tried to remove M. El Naschie's name
    from our paper but it was not possible. Ginsparg wanted everybody to read about this fiasco.

    I apologize to Michael Green for having been very harsh to him in Trieste, at the Dirac Medal celebration. At the time I honestly believed that M. El Naschie was a member of Cambridge. I even defended El Naschie by attacking Michael Green ... what an idiot was I !!!

    I could say *many* more things about this character but out of respect for his lovely wife and daughters, brother and friends, I will refrain from doing so.

    Carlos Castro Perelman

    ReplyDelete
  15. "Am I to blame for having Mohammed El Naschie used illictly the Cambridge DAMTP affiliation for years ?"

    No!

    "I could say *many* more things about this character but out of respect for his lovely wife and daughters, brother and friends, I will refrain from doing so."

    Please, please tell us more. You can email me if you prefer. hasten dot jason at gmail dot com. Have you met El Naschie and his family? You refer to his wife. Do you mean Lydia Thorsen, or Mervat Heddini?

    ReplyDelete