Sunday, December 5, 2010

Latest comments from SCIAM and FQXi-395

Readers may recall that E-infinity Group, who posted many long screeds to FQXi-395, flounced out in April:

E-Infinity wrote on Apr. 24, 2010 @ 13:47 GMT
Dear Ray

The bureau of E-Infinity in China has taken the view that it is useless to continue any meaningful scientific discussion on this blog. Consequently, they have established an E-Infinity Communication Journal. This will fill the gap and satisfy a need after the censorship imposed worldwide and the close down of Chaos, Solitons & Fractals and scaling it down to a run of the mill journal of nonlinear dynamics. We think you for your encouraging remark though and will consider posting comments now and then. However the bulk of our work will be this new blog or Journal if you want. The home of the Journal will be either the Middle East or the Far East to keep it safe from vandalisms. Once more thank you Ray for your balanced comment and your increased awareness of the importance of our work towards which you have contributed in non trivial ways. In particular your E12 holds promises for future development.

Best regards,


They copied all the old screeds to E-Infinity - High Energy Communications and began adding new ones there. (See E-infinity communications 38, 39 and 40 to read the latest ones on El Naschie Watch.)

So it is a surprise to see that screed No. 40 is one of several new posts on FQXi-395. Click here to read the latest from FQXi-395 in our archive.

Screed No. 40 was also posted by Elly Sehrmann as comments 28-33 on Lisi and Weatherall's A Geometric Theory of Everything on SCIAM. (We looked critically at the first couple of sentences in The inimitable El Naschie writing style.)

Luboš Motl slammed Lisi and Weatherall on November 18, but he didn't mention El Naschie.

Now there are more SCIAM comments on Lisi and Weatherall. 34 and 35 from Paula.Ray and 36 from loch96 are from someone in the Naschie Party, probably the great man himself. They all are afflicted with the broken quotation mark syndrome. In comment 36, loch96 pretends to be having a conversation with Elly Sehrmann about her comment 33, as if Elly were a different person. The Naschie Party want to appear numerous.

Translate English to Arabic
محمد النشائى El Naschie Watch محمد النشائي El Naschie News محمد النشائى محمد النشائي All El Naschie All The Time محمد النشائى

No comments:

Post a Comment